Rhetorical
Rhetorical defended the title he won in 2025. After the Turf Classic Stakes, this was the second Group 1 win of the season for the winner. He is one of 5 different Group 1 winners this season for sire Not This Time.

Rhetorical defended the title he won in 2025. After the Turf Classic Stakes, this was the second Group 1 win of the season for the winner. He is one of 5 different Group 1 winners this season for sire Not This Time.
Not This Time had already sired a winner of this race: Up to the Mark (2023). With this win, the stallion moved to 7 Group 1 wins this season, one win behind leader Night Of Thunder in the 2026 sires' table.
Rhetorical is out of Sheet Humor (Distorted Humor) and is the best of her three winners. He is a half-brother to Sterling Silver (Cupid), a multiple stakes winner and multiple graded-placed.
Second dam Sheets (Scatmandu) won the Grade 3 Azalea Breeders' Cup S. on dirt and the Turf Amazon H. over five furlongs on turf at Philadelphia Park in 2008.
Third dam One Hot Minute (Relaunch).
Sheet Humor produced a colt by Central Banker in 2022 and was most recently covered by Preservationist.
| Year | Winner | Trainer / Jockey | Owner / Breeder | Video | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | RhetoricalNot This Time × Sheet Humor | William WaldenIrad Ortiz Jr | Gary Barber, Cheyenne Stable, LLC and Wachtel StableMallory Mort & Karen Mort | ||
| 2024 | Carl SpacklerLope De Vega × Zindaya | Chad C BrownTyler Gaffalione | E Five Racing Thoroughbreds LlcFifth Avenue Bloodstock | ||
| 2023 | Up to the MarkNot This Time × Belle's Finale | Todd PletcherJose L Ortiz | Repole Stable & St. Elias StableRamspring Farm | ||
| 2022 | AnnapolisWar Front × My Miss Sophia | Todd PletcherIrad Ortiz Jr | Bass RacingBass Stables | ||
| 2021 | In LoveAgnes Gold × Last Bet | Paulo LoboAlex Achard | Bonne Chance Farm & Stud R D IFazenda Mondesir / Stud Rio Dois Irmaos | ||
| 2020 | IvarAgnes Gold × May Be Now | Paulo LoboJoseph Talamo | Bonne Chance Farm & Stud R D IStud R D I |